The Great Mate Debate: NO! Two Creatures? BIG MISTAKE!

In chapter 17, Frankenstein’s creature asks Victor Frankenstein to make him a female companion. They proceed to argue about the wisdom of the choice. Eventually, Frankenstein relents and agrees to make the companion, only to reverse his decision a few chapters later.



Refer to the arguments (quote at least one directly) that VF and the Creature offer for and against making a female companion. Can you think of any additional reasons for or against making a female companion? Whose side do you feel more sympathy for? What do you think VF should do?
Post your response here, then be sure to read your classmate's postings, as well. Respond to at least ONE member of the class -- someone who disagrees with you, that is... When you respond, please begin your response, "In response to ____________'s comment,"

If you have questions, send me a quick email. karri_landeis@bismarckschools.org

The Great Mate Debate: Yes! This monster needs a mate!

In chapter 17, Frankenstein’s creature asks Victor Frankenstein to make him a female companion. They proceed to argue about the wisdom of the choice. Eventually, Frankenstein relents and agrees to make the companion, only to reverse his decision a few chapters later.

Refer to the arguments (quote at least one directly) that VF and the Creature offer for and against making a female companion. Can you think of any additional reasons for or against making a female companion? Whose side do you feel more sympathy for? What do you think VF should do? 

Post your response here, then be sure to read your classmate's postings, as well.  Respond to at least ONE member of the class -- someone who disagrees with you, that is...  When you respond, please begin your response, "In response to ____________'s comment," 

If you have questions, send me a quick email.  karri_landeis@bismarckschools.org